What do you think of fiberglass insulation? I am reevaluating my negative opinion

I am always looking for experts in the construction industry to discuss best practices. At Construct this year I met Andy McIntyre with Knauf Insulation. Our discussion went something like this:

Me: “Andy, great to finally meet you, I don’t have any use for your product.”

Andy: “Here are the many many reasons why you are wrong and should use my product on a regular basis.”

Ok, that is not exactly how the conversation went, but I am not stretching too much. Andy is an expert. I pretend to be an expert. We had a discussion, Andy gave me enough valuable information to reconsider my “expert” ideas about fiberglass insulation. I asked him to put in writing his reasons to continue our discussion. This is what he sent me. Let me know your thoughts:

“Not your father’s insulation: Today’s glass mineral wool insulation is a high performance, proven, sustainable product perfectly suited for green building. Today’s glass mineral wool products, in batt, blanket, or blown in form can achieve R 4.2 per inch, placing it as the highest performing non-foam material available. Glass wool insulation is comfortable to work with. Prior formulations with larger fibers and a Phenol formaldehyde binder (PF) had caused brashness in the product. In today’s products, PF has been replaced by bio based binders derived from corn.


Glass wool insulation is safe, and is no longer considered a possible carcinogen. No other building material has been as exhaustively tested as glass wool, aka fiberglass. It has been completely exonerated. Any claims otherwise are completely false, and misleading. Today’s glass wool is unsurpassed in sustainability. Featuring high post-consumer recycled content, today’s materials meet stringent Red List Free status, and have Environmental Product Declarations (EPD’s) available. Today’s glass wool products are comfortable to work with, offer proven high performance, and are sustainable.”

So, which insulation product on the market is the best for a high performance healthy house in your opinion?

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.